§ 8-4-203 - Permits generally.
8-4-203. Permits generally.
(a) The Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality or its successor is given and charged with the power and duty to issue, continue in effect, revoke, modify, or deny permits, under such conditions as it may prescribe:
(1) To prevent, control, or abate pollution;
(2) For the discharge of sewage, industrial waste, or other wastes into the waters of the state, including the disposal of pollutants into wells; and
(3) For the installation, modification, or operation of disposal systems or any part of them.
(b) (1) (A) (i) The department shall not issue, modify, or renew a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit or state permit for a nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works without the permit applicant first demonstrating to the department its financial ability to cover the estimated costs of operating and maintaining the nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works for a minimum period of five (5) years.
(ii) For purposes of this section, "nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works" means a device or system operated by an entity other than a city, town, borough, county, or sewer improvement district that treats, in whole or in part, waste or wastewater from humans or household operations and must continuously operate to protect human health and the environment despite a permittee's failure to maintain or operate the treatment works.
(iii) State or federal facilities, schools, universities, and colleges are specifically exempted from the requirements of this section.
(iv) Each permit application for a nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works submitted under this section shall be accompanied by a cost estimate for a third party to operate and maintain the nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works each year for a period of five (5) years.
(B) (i) The department shall not issue or modify a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit or a state permit for a nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works that proposes to use a new technology that, in the discretion of the department, cannot be verified to meet permit requirements without the applicant first demonstrating its financial ability to replace the new technology with a nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works that uses technology acceptable to the department.
(ii) Each permit application for a nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works that proposes to use a new technology that in the discretion of the department cannot be verified to meet permit requirements shall be accompanied by a cost estimate to replace the proposed system with a nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works that uses technology acceptable to the department.
(2) The applicant's financial ability to operate and maintain the nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works for a period of five (5) years shall be demonstrated to the department by:
(A) Obtaining insurance that specifically covers operation and maintenance costs;
(B) Obtaining a letter of credit;
(C) Obtaining a surety bond;
(D) Obtaining a trust fund or an escrow account; or
(E) Using a combination of insurance, letter of credit, surety bond, trust fund, or escrow account.
(3) The department may reduce or waive the amount of the required financial assurance if the permit applicant can demonstrate to the department's satisfaction that:
(A) For a renewal permit, during the five (5) years preceding the application for a renewal permit, the nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works facility has:
(i) Remained in continuous operation;
(ii) Received no more than three (3) permit violations within a six-month period as set out in the permit issued by the department;
(iii) Maintained the services of a certified wastewater treatment operator, where applicable;
(iv) Remained financially solvent; and
(v) Operated the facility's nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works to prevent the discharge of waterborne pollutants in unacceptable concentrations to the surface waters or groundwater of the state as defined in the permit or as defined in the state's water quality standards; or
(B) For a new permit, that the reduction or waiver is necessary to accommodate important economic or social development in the area of the proposed nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works facility and that the applicant has shown a history of financial responsibility and compliance with regulatory requirements in other relevant ventures.
(4) The department has discretion to withdraw a reduction or waiver granted under this subsection at any time in order to protect human health or the environment.
(5) A financial instrument required by this section shall be posted to the benefit of the department and shall remain in effect for the life of the permit.
(6) It is explicitly understood that the department shall not directly operate and shall not be responsible for the operation of any nonmunicipal domestic sewage treatment works.
(c) (1) (A) (i) All facilities that engage in land application or storage of fluids generated or utilized during exploration or production phases of oil or gas operations shall be closed in a manner that ensures protection of human health and the environment.
(ii) As used in this subsection, "land application or storage of fluids generated or utilized during exploration or production phases of oil or gas operations" means land farming through the controlled and repeated application of drilling fluids to a soil surface or the practice of receiving and storing said fluids from offsite for waste management.
(iii) Surface facilities associated with Class II injection wells are specifically excluded from the requirements of this subsection.
(iv) Land applications at the drilling or exploration site that are authorized under any general permit issued by the department are excluded from the requirements of this subsection.
(B) By October 1, 2009, each existing permitted facility regulated under this subsection shall submit to the department the following:
(i) A plan to close the permitted facility and make any site restoration deemed necessary by the department;
(ii) A detailed cost estimate to close and restore the permitted facility that meets the requirements of this subsection and is approved by the department; and
(iii) A financial mechanism that demonstrates to the department's satisfaction the permittee's financial ability to ensure adequate closure and any necessary restoration of the permitted facility in accordance with the requirements of this subsection.
(C) The department shall not issue, modify, or renew a permit for facilities regulated under this subsection without the permit applicant first demonstrating to the department's satisfaction the applicant's financial ability to ensure adequate closure and any necessary restoration of the permitted facility in accordance with the requirements of this subsection.
(D) (i) The amount of any financial assurance required under this subsection shall be equal to or greater than the detailed cost estimate for a third party to close the permitted facility in accordance with closure plans approved by the department.
(ii) The detailed cost estimate shall be prepared by an independent professional consultant.
(iii) On or before August 15 of each year, a permittee shall submit to the department for approval a detailed cost estimate to close and restore the permitted facility in accordance with closure plans that have been approved by the department.
(E) (i) For new permits, the applicant shall submit to the department for approval a detailed cost estimate to close and restore the facility based on the proposed operation and capacity of the facility from the date the permit is issued through the following October 1.
(ii) For renewal or modification applications, the permittee shall submit to the department for approval a detailed cost estimate to close and restore the permitted facility based on closure plans that have been approved by the department.
(F) (i) For each permit, the financial assurance mechanism shall be renewed on October 1 of each year.
(ii) For each permit, documentation that the required financial assurance mechanism has been renewed beginning October 1 of that year shall be received by the department by September 15 of each year or the department shall initiate procedures to:
(a) Take possession of the funds guaranteed by the financial assurance mechanism; and
(b) (1) Suspend or revoke the permit under which the facility is operated.
(2) A permit shall remain suspended until a financial assurance mechanism is provided to the department in accordance with this subsection.
(iii) The permittee is responsible for ensuring that documentation of annual renewal is received by the department by its due date.
(2) The permittee or applicant shall demonstrate financial ability to adequately close or restore the land application or storage facility by:
(A) Obtaining insurance that specifically covers closure and restoration costs;
(B) Obtaining a letter of credit;
(C) Obtaining a bond or other surety instrument;
(D) Creating a trust fund or an escrow account;
(E) Combining any of the instruments in (c)(2)(A)-(D); or
(F) Any other financial instrument approved by the director.
(3) A financial instrument required by this subsection shall:
(A) Be posted to the benefit of the department;
(B) Provide that the financial instrument cannot be cancelled without sixty (60) days prior written notice addressed to the department's legal division chief as evidenced by a signed, certified mail with a return receipt request; and
(C) Be reviewed by the department upon receipt of the cancellation notice to determine whether to initiate procedures to revoke or suspend the facility's permit and whether to initiate procedures to take possession of the funds guaranteed by the financial assurance mechanism.
(4) Before the department may release a financial assurance mechanism, the department shall receive a certification by a professional engineer that the permitted facility has been closed and restored in accordance with closure plans that have been approved by the department.
(5) The department is not responsible for the operation, closure, or restoration of a facility regulated under this subsection.
(d) (1) When an application for the issuance of a new permit or a major modification of an existing permit is filed with the department, the department shall cause notice of the application to be published in a newspaper of general circulation in the county in which the proposed facility is to be located.
(2) The notice required by subdivision (d)(1) of this section shall advise that any interested person may request a public hearing on the permit application by giving the department a written request within ten (10) days of the publication of the notice.
(3) If the department determines that a hearing is necessary or desires such a hearing, the department shall schedule a public hearing and shall notify by first class mail the applicant and all persons that have submitted comments of the date, time, and place of the public hearing.
(e) (1) (A) Whenever the department proposes to grant or deny any permit application, it shall cause notice of its proposed action to be published in either:
(i) A newspaper of general circulation in the county in which the facility that is the subject of the application is located; or
(ii) In the case of a statewide permit, in a newspaper of general circulation in the state.
(B) The notice shall afford any interested party thirty (30) calendar days in which to submit comments on the proposed permit action.
(C) At the conclusion of the public comment period, the department shall announce in writing its final decision regarding the permit application.
(2) (A) (i) The department's final decision shall include a response to each issue raised in any public comments received during the public comment period. The response shall manifest reasoned consideration of the issues raised by the public comments and shall be supported by appropriate legal, scientific, or practical reasons for accepting or rejecting the substance of the comment in the department's permitting decision.
(ii) For the purposes of this section, response to comments by the department should serve the roles of both developing the record for possible judicial review of an individual permitting action and as a record for the public's review of the department's technical and legal interpretations on long-range regulatory issues.
(iii) Nothing in this section, however, shall be construed as limiting the department's authority to raise all relevant issues of regulatory concern upon adjudicatory review of the commission of a particular permitting action.
(B) (i) In the case of any discharge limit, emission limit, environmental standard, analytical method, or monitoring requirements, the record of the proposed action and the response shall include a written explanation of the rationale for the proposal, demonstrating that any technical requirements or standards are based upon generally accepted scientific knowledge and engineering practices.
(ii) For any standard or requirement that is identical to an applicable regulation, this demonstration may be satisfied by reference to the regulation. In all other cases, the department must provide its own justification with appropriate reference to the scientific and engineering literature or written studies conducted by the department.
(f) (1) All costs of publication of notices of applications and notices of proposals to grant permits under this section shall be the responsibility of the applicant.
(2) All costs of publication of notices of proposals to deny a permit under this section shall be the responsibility of the department.
(3) Any moneys received under subsection (f) of this section shall be classified as refunds to expenditures.
(g) Only those persons that submit comments on the record during the public comment period and the applicant shall have standing to appeal the decision of the department to the Arkansas Pollution Control and Ecology Commission.
(h) (1) Permits for the discharge of pollutants into the waters of the state or for the prevention of pollution of the waters of the state shall remain freely transferable, provided the applicant for the transfer notifies the Director of the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality at least thirty (30) days in advance of the proposed transfer date and submits a disclosure statement as required by 8-1-106.
(2) Only those reasons set out in 8-1-106(b)(1) and (c) constitute grounds for denial of a transfer.
(3) The permit is automatically transferred to the new permittee unless the director denies the request within thirty (30) days of the receipt of the disclosure statement.
(i) In the event of voluminous comments, including without limitation a petition, the department may require the designation of a representative to accept any notices required by this section.
(j) The notice provisions of subsections (d) and (e) of this section do not apply to permit transfers or minor modifications of existing permits.
(k) This section in no way restricts local and county government entities from enacting more stringent ordinances regulating nonmunicipal domestic treatment sewage systems in Arkansas.
(l) The commission may promulgate rules to establish a permit-by-rule. A permit-by-rule is subject to the public notice requirements and procedural provisions under 8-4-202 et seq. but is not subject to the public notice requirements and procedural provisions under 8-4-203 -- 8-4-205.