Search Results
| Case name | Citation | Summary |
| [Arizona] IVO QUEIROZ v DANIEL HARVEY | 2009/04/28 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CV-08-0308-PR Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz; W. Scott Bales, Concur |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v BRIAN JEFFREY DANN | 2009/05/19 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CR-07-0153-AP Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Philip Hall, ConcurConstitutionality DecisionHolding A.R.S. § 13-703.01 (aggravation and penalty phases of capital trials) constitutional and not violative of Ariz. Const. art 2 § 10 (double jeopardy clause), U.S. Const. amend 5 (double jeopardy clause). Holding A.R.S. § 13-751(F)(8) ("multiple homicides" aggravating factor) constitutional and not vague because of a clarifying jury instruction and not violative of Ariz. Const. art. 2 § 4 (due process clause), U.S. Const. amends. 5, 14 (due process clause), or Ariz. Const. art. 2, § 23 (unanimous jury verdicts requirement). |
| [Arizona] AZ MINORITY COALITION et al v AZ INDEPENDENT et al | 2009/05/20 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CV-08-0161-PR Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur in part; Garye L Vasquez, Concur in part |
| [Arizona] RYAN JOHN CHRONIS v HON. STEINLE/ANDREW THOMAS | 2009/06/03 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CV-08-0394-SA W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v WESTERN UNION | 2009/06/03 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CV-08-0241-PR Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Philip G Espinosa, Dissent; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v MICHAEL DIMETRIUS SCHMIDT | 2009/06/03 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CR-08-0308-PR W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, ConcurConstitutionality DecisionHolding A.R.S. § 13-702(D)(13) ("catch-all" aggravator) unconstitutional if the sole factor considered to increase a maximum statutory sentence under U.S. Const. amend. 14 (due process). |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v SEAN WAYNE BOTKIN | 2009/06/03 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CR-08-0299-PR Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v JESUS VALVERDE JR | 2009/06/03 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CR-08-0292-PR W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v VINCENT ZARAGOZA | 2009/06/03 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CR-08-0286-PR Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur |
| [Arizona] SABINO CARBAJAL v ICA/PHELPS DODGE/GABB ROBBINS | 2009/06/15 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CV-08-0359-PR Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v PATRICK WADE BEARUP | 2009/07/17 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CR-07-0048-AP Rebecca White Berch, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur |
| [Arizona] AZ EARLY CHILDHOOD v BREWER/MARTIN/PARTRIDGE | 2009/07/24 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CV-09-0078-SA Michael D. Ryan, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v JULIUS JARREAU MOORE | 2009/07/24 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CR-07-0164-AP W. Scott Bales, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Daniel A Barker, ConcurConstitutionality DecisionHolding A.R.S. §§ 13-751 to -759 (capital sentencing scheme) constitutional under U.S. Const. amends. 8 (cruel and unusual punishment) and 14 (due process). |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v PAUL BRADLEY SPEER | 2009/07/24 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CR-07-0103-AP Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Ruth V. McGregor, ConcurConstitutionality DecisionHolding A.R.S. § 13-751(C) (burden of establishing mitigating circumstances) constitutional under U.S. Const. amend. 8 (cruel and unusual punishment). |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v ALVIE COPELAND KILES | 2009/08/10 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CR-06-0240 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Ruth V. McGregor, ConcurConstitutionality DecisionHolding A.R.S. § 13-751(F)(8) constitutional under U.S. Const. amend. 8 (cruel and unusual punishment). |
| [Arizona] JANICE K BREWER v ROBERT BURNS/KIRK ADAMS et al | 2009/08/13 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CV-09-0168 W. Scott Bales, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur in the Result |
| [Arizona] LEONEL GARZA v SWIFT TRANSPORTATION | 2009/08/24 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CV-08-0382 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v DANNY RAY HARDESTY | 2009/09/08 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CR-08-0244-PR Rebecca White Berch, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur |
| [Arizona] DAVID LAKE v CITY OF PHOENIX et al | 2009/10/29 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CV-09-0036 W. Scott Bales, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur |
| [Arizona] STATE OF ARIZONA v MARK ALLEN FREENEY | 2009/12/04 | Court: Arizona Supreme Court Docket No: CR-08-0363-PR A. John Pelander, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur |