Find Court Cases > Minn. Star & Trib. Co. v. MN Comm. of Rev.

Minn. Star & Trib. Co. v. MN Comm. of Rev.

Case Date: 01/12/1983
Docket No: none

Facts of the Case 

From 1967 to 1971, the Minneapolis Star and Tribune Company, a publisher of a morning and evening newspaper in Minneapolis, was exempt from a state sales and use tax provided periodic publications. In 1971, the Minnesota legislature imposed a "use tax" on the cost of paper and ink products consumed in publishing. In 1974, the legislature exempted the first $100,000 worth of ink and paper consumed a year. After the enactment of this exemption, the Star Tribune found itself paying roughly two-thirds of the total revenue raised by the tax.

Question 

Did the taxing scheme enacted by the Minnesota legislature violate the freedom of press guaranteed by the First Amendment?

Argument Minn. Star & Trib. Co. v. MN Comm. of Rev. - Oral ArgumentFull Transcript Text  Download MP3Minn. Star & Trib. Co. v. MN Comm. of Rev. - Opinion Announcement  Download MP3 Conclusion  Decision: 8 votes for Minn. Star & Trib. Co., 1 vote(s) against Legal provision: Amendment 1: Speech, Press, and Assembly

The Court held that while the First Amendment did not prohibit all regulation of the press, Minnesota had "created a special tax that applie[d] only to certain publications protected by the First Amendment." Noting that there was "substantial evidence that differential taxation of the press would have troubled the Framers of the First Amendment," the Court held that when states single out the press "the threat of burdensome taxes becomes acute." The Court concluded that "recognizing a power in the State not only to single out the press but also to tailor the tax so that it singles out a few members of the press presents such a potential for abuse that no interest suggested by Minnesota can justify the scheme."